Understanding Real Estate Compensation

NAR Settlement: What Changed for Home Sellers?

The NAR settlement changed how real estate broker compensation is communicated and documented. It did not eliminate commissions or establish what you must pay to sell your home.

Since August 17, 2024, offers of buyer-broker compensation can no longer appear on covered Multiple Listing Services (MLSs), and MLS participants working with buyers must obtain written buyer agreements before touring homes with them in person or through live virtual tours.

As a seller, you can negotiate what you pay your listing broker and decide whether to authorize compensation for the buyer's broker, subject to your written agreements. Broker compensation was negotiable before the settlement and remains negotiable today.

By Jim Whatley, Broker/Owner, Uber Realty LLC
Content reviewed:

Start here: What am I paying my listing broker, what might I pay the buyer's broker, and how will those decisions affect the money I receive at closing?

Those are separate decisions. You should understand each one before signing a listing agreement or accepting an offer.

Your Money and Your Decisions

What does the NAR settlement mean for me as a seller?

The most useful way to understand the settlement is to separate the decisions you make when hiring a listing broker from the decisions you make when negotiating with a buyer.

What will I pay my listing broker?

This is the compensation you agree to pay for representing you in the sale. Ask what services are included, how the fee is calculated and when payment becomes due.

Will I pay the buyer's broker?

You may authorize buyer-broker compensation or consider a request for it when an offer arrives. The settlement does not require you to offer a particular amount.

Will I contribute toward buyer expenses?

A buyer may request seller concessions toward eligible expenses, such as certain closing costs. These are separate from broker compensation and may be subject to financing and contract requirements.

How much money will I receive?

Your estimated net proceeds depend on the sale price, broker compensation, concessions, mortgage payoff, taxes, repairs, closing expenses and other applicable costs.

My recommendation: Ask for these amounts to be shown separately in dollars. A combined commission percentage does not tell you enough about what you are paying, who is receiving it or what you will keep.

Before and After August 17, 2024

Which real estate rules actually changed?

The National Association of Realtors (NAR) announced a settlement in March 2024 involving litigation over real estate broker commissions. Important resulting practice changes took effect on August 17, 2024.

The comparison below distinguishes those changes from the compensation decisions that were already negotiable.

On smaller screens, scroll across the table. Keyboard users can focus the table and use the arrow keys to scroll.

Real estate broker compensation: before and after the 2024 NAR practice changes
Selling Decision Before August 17, 2024 From August 17, 2024
Buyer-broker compensation offers Compensation offers could appear in MLS compensation fields. Covered MLSs prohibit compensation offers. Offers may still be communicated through permitted channels outside the MLS.
Written buyer agreements Requirements varied according to applicable laws, policies and brokerage practices. MLS participants working with buyers must obtain written agreements before in-person or live virtual home tours.
Compensation disclosure Compensation could be communicated through the MLS and other permitted channels. Buyer agreements must contain ascertainable compensation terms, a compensation limit and a clear negotiability disclosure. Off-MLS compensation communication remains permitted.
Seller authorization Compensation was negotiable and governed by applicable agreements and rules. Prior written seller authorization specifying the amount or rate is required before a covered participant offers or pays buyer-broker compensation on the seller's behalf.
Listing-broker fee Negotiable and not set by law. Still negotiable and not set by law.
Total selling costs Depended on the transaction, selling price and agreements. Still depend on the transaction, selling price and agreements. The settlement establishes no universal commission rate.

The important distinction is that the rules governing communication and documentation changed. Your ability to negotiate broker compensation did not begin with the settlement.

For the applicable policy details, see the NAR settlement FAQs.

Buyer-Broker Compensation

Do I still have to pay the buyer's real estate broker?

No. The NAR settlement does not require you to pay the buyer's broker. You may decide whether to authorize compensation, how much to authorize or whether to consider a request when an offer is presented.

However, you must understand and honor any obligations you have already accepted in your signed agreements. The settlement does not automatically cancel those obligations.

Can compensation still be offered outside the MLS?

Yes. Removing compensation offers from covered MLSs did not prohibit those offers elsewhere. Compensation may still be communicated through permitted off-MLS channels.

If your listing broker is going to offer or pay compensation to a buyer's broker on your behalf under the applicable NAR practice requirements, your prior written authorization is required. That authorization must identify the amount or rate.

What if the buyer asks me to pay?

A buyer may include a request for buyer-broker compensation in a purchase offer. You can accept the request, negotiate it or decline it, subject to any existing contractual obligations.

Before deciding, consider what the buyer is offering for your house, what expenses they want you to cover and the remaining terms of the transaction.

A compensation request is part of the negotiation. I would rather help you evaluate what the entire offer means for your net proceeds than recommend accepting or rejecting it because of one percentage.

Read NAR's consumer guidance on compensation offers for additional information about seller authorization and payment choices.

Buyer Agreements and Home Showings

Do buyers need a signed agreement before seeing my home?

An MLS participant working with a buyer must enter into a written agreement with that buyer before an in-person or live virtual home tour.

The agreement establishes the terms under which the broker provides services to the buyer. Under the applicable practice changes, its compensation provisions must meet several requirements.

  • The agreement must identify a specific compensation amount or a method that allows the amount to be determined objectively.
  • Compensation cannot be left open-ended or defined simply as whatever the seller offers.
  • Compensation received by the buyer's broker from all sources cannot exceed the amount or rate agreed to with the buyer.
  • The agreement must clearly and prominently disclose that broker compensation is negotiable and is not established by law.

Does everyone attending an open house need a buyer agreement?

No. An unrepresented person independently attending an open house does not need to sign a written buyer agreement merely to visit the property.

Likewise, an agent hosting an open house solely in the role of representing the seller is not required by this practice change to obtain buyer agreements from visitors the agent is not working with as buyers.

If an MLS participant begins working with a visitor as a buyer, the applicable written-agreement requirement must be satisfied before touring a home with that buyer.

These are covered MLS practice requirements, not a nationwide law requiring every person entering a home to sign a buyer representation agreement.

Why this matters when you receive an offer

A buyer may already have agreed to compensate their broker before seeing your property. They may therefore ask you to contribute toward that expense when making an offer.

The buyer's agreement does not, by itself, obligate you to pay their broker. Your own agreements and any terms you subsequently accept determine your obligations.

Additional guidance: Written Buyer Agreements 101 and NAR's open-house and written-agreement guidance.

Evaluating an Offer

Should I agree to pay buyer-broker compensation?

There is no single answer that fits every seller or every offer.

You may receive an offer that requests no buyer-broker payment, another that requests compensation and another that includes both compensation and a contribution toward buyer closing costs.

The amount requested matters, but so do the price, financing, contingencies and likelihood of the transaction reaching closing.

What will I keep?

Compare the estimated seller net proceeds after deducting compensation, concessions and other applicable selling expenses.

How strong is the offer?

Review financing, deposit terms, appraisal and inspection contingencies, closing timing and other conditions that may affect the sale.

What have I agreed to?

Review your existing written compensation authorizations, listing agreement and proposed purchase contract before making a decision.

Look at the whole offer. An offer requesting compensation is not necessarily worse than one that requests none. A higher purchase price, fewer concessions or more favorable contract terms may change which offer works best for you.

My recommendation is to compare the offers on paper, in dollars, while also considering the risks and obligations attached to each one.

Understanding the Cost of Representation

What does a lower listing fee actually mean in dollars?

One decision you can address before your home goes on the market is what you will pay your listing broker.

Suppose you are comparing a hypothetical 3% listing-side fee with a 1% listing-side fee. At the same sale price, with the same buyer-broker compensation and other expenses, the arithmetic difference is two percentage points of the sale price.

The following examples show what that difference would look like at three hypothetical sale prices.

These are listing-side arithmetic examples, not actual client transactions, market-average commission rates or guaranteed savings. Scroll across the table on smaller screens.

Hypothetical 3% versus 1% listing-side fee comparison
Sale Price 3% Listing Fee 1% Listing Fee Difference
$450,000 $13,500 $4,500 $9,000
$650,000 $19,500 $6,500 $13,000
$325,000 $9,750 $3,250 $6,500

Assumptions: identical sale prices within each comparison, the stated hypothetical listing-side percentages, and identical buyer-broker compensation and other selling expenses. The figures are percentage calculations only. Actual fees and services depend on the applicable written agreements.

Neither 3% nor 1% is an industry-mandated rate. The comparison does not assume what another brokerage charges or establish that every brokerage provides identical services.

If you have received a listing proposal, enter its actual listing-side fee into our calculator rather than assuming what another broker might charge.

Real estate broker compensation is negotiable and is not set by law. Uber Realty listing-side compensation is separate from any seller-authorized buyer-broker compensation, concessions, repairs and other transaction costs. Exact fees, services and terms are controlled by the current written agreement.

Before You Sign

Which documents should I review when selling my home?

You do not need to become an expert on the settlement to sell your home. You do need to understand the documents that determine what you are agreeing to pay.

Your listing agreement

Review the services, listing-side compensation, agreement duration, payment obligations and cancellation provisions.

Ask: What am I paying my listing broker, what is included and when could that payment become due?

Buyer-broker compensation authorization

If you authorize compensation to another broker, understand the amount or rate, when the authorization applies and how it is documented.

Ask: What am I authorizing, and what obligations does that authorization create?

The purchase offer and related agreements

Review the purchase price, requested compensation, concessions and transaction conditions. Make sure any agreed payments are documented appropriately.

Ask: What changes financially and contractually if I accept this offer?

Your estimated seller net sheet

Request an itemized estimate of what you may receive after mortgage payoff, compensation, concessions and other selling costs.

Ask: What is my anticipated net amount, and which expenses remain estimates?

Do not wait until closing to understand the numbers. An estimated net sheet is a decision tool, not a guarantee of final proceeds. Review it when comparing offers and update it as transaction details change.

Ask your broker to explain the agreements and compensation provisions. If you need legal advice about an obligation or contract interpretation, consult a Florida real estate attorney.

Choosing Your Representation

Can I choose what I pay my listing broker without choosing less representation?

When comparing listing proposals, look at the work you need your broker to perform, not just the percentage in the agreement.

At Uber Realty, the 1% Listing and the 2% Listing, With Hands-On Help share the same core professional representation and marketing, subject to the current written agreement.

The difference is the amount of additional in-person help you need at the property, not an additional level of advertising.

Simple Fee is a different payment choice within the 1% Listing, not a separate service package.

I recommend comparing the options based on your actual situation. If you live locally and can handle arrangements at the property, your needs may differ from those of a homeowner who has already relocated.

The settlement does not require you to select a particular brokerage or compensation arrangement. Your choice should reflect the representation, service and cost that work for you.

Real estate broker compensation is negotiable and is not set by law. Uber Realty listing-side compensation is separate from any seller-authorized buyer-broker compensation, concessions, repairs and other transaction costs. Exact fees, services and terms are controlled by the current written agreement.

Historical Settlement Claims

Can I still receive a real estate commission settlement payment?

Status as of November 21, 2026: The Residential Real Estate Broker Commissions Antitrust Settlements administrator identifies the following past claims deadlines:

  • May 9, 2025: Claims deadline for the earlier settlements identified by the administrator.
  • December 30, 2025: Claims deadline for the later settlements identified by the administrator.

Both dates have passed. If you previously submitted a claim or have questions about a possible late submission, eligibility or distribution, consult the official settlement administrator's FAQ for current information.

Acceptance of a late claim and receipt of a payment are not guaranteed. These historical dates do not establish that every real estate commission lawsuit or possible claim opportunity has closed.

Claims involving previous transactions are separate from the compensation decisions you make when selling your home today.

Frequently Asked Questions

What else should home sellers know about the NAR settlement?

Did the NAR settlement eliminate the 6% real estate commission?

No. The settlement did not abolish real estate commissions or establish a new required rate. There was no universal commission rate set by law before the settlement, and there is none established by the settlement. Broker compensation remains negotiable.

Can I refuse to pay the buyer's broker?

Yes, you can decline a request for buyer-broker compensation, subject to obligations you have already accepted in written agreements. Evaluate the purchase price, requested compensation, concessions and other offer terms together before deciding whether to accept, negotiate or decline the offer.

How will buyers know if I am offering compensation to their broker?

Offers of buyer-broker compensation may be communicated through permitted channels outside the MLS. Removing compensation offers from covered MLSs does not make that information universally confidential or prohibit buyers and their brokers from discussing available compensation.

Can a buyer's broker receive more than the amount in the buyer agreement?

Under the applicable NAR practice requirements, no. The buyer's broker cannot receive total compensation from any source exceeding the amount or rate agreed to with the buyer. A seller's offer of compensation does not override that limit.

Can I still negotiate my listing broker's fee?

Yes. Listing-broker compensation was negotiable before the settlement and remains negotiable today. Compare the services, compensation terms and payment obligations in each proposal. Your current written agreement controls the exact fees and services.

Does selling my home now qualify me for a settlement payment?

Not automatically. Historical settlement claims are governed by their own eligibility requirements and claims procedures. The identified claims deadlines in 2025 have passed. Consult the official settlement administrator for current case-specific information. Claim acceptance and payment are not guaranteed.

Sources and Further Reading

Where can I verify the settlement rules for myself?

The National Association of Realtors provides guidance on the practice changes arising from its settlement. The settlement administrator provides separate information concerning historical claims, eligibility and distribution.

These sources serve different purposes. Review the applicable agreements and rules when making a decision about your own transaction.

The NAR Practice Changes

Settlement Questions and Claims

This page provides general real estate information and brokerage guidance. It is not legal advice or a substitute for reviewing the agreements, rules and legal requirements applicable to your transaction.

Know What You Are Paying

What will these decisions mean for your sale?

I can show you the listing-side fee, any proposed buyer-broker compensation and other estimated selling costs separately, using an assumed sale price for your home.

If you are selling in Niceville, Fort Walton Beach or Shalimar, we can compare the representation and hands-on help you need before you choose. I'm Jim Whatley, Broker/Owner of Uber Realty.

Real estate broker compensation is negotiable and is not set by law. Uber Realty listing-side compensation is separate from any seller-authorized buyer-broker compensation, concessions, repairs and other transaction costs. Exact fees, services and terms are controlled by the current written agreement.

Jim Whatley, Broker/Owner, Uber Realty LLC. Florida Broker License BK3174026. Florida Brokerage License CQ1038333. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Property, association, permit, flood, insurance and other information can differ by address and may change. Verify material property-specific information with the appropriate source or professional before relying on it.